Most patient billing questions by phone come down to five: what do I owe, why do I owe it, did my insurance pay, can I pay over time, and what will this cost. The front desk can usually answer the first and third from the account and should route the rest to billing, with the question written out in full and a callback time the patient is given. Cost questions from uninsured or self pay patients carry a federal rule: any inquiry about potential costs counts as a request for a good faith estimate, due within three business days.
Our phone scripts post has one short billing script. This post covers the whole call type: who should answer what, how to word the hard ones, and what to fix so billing calls stop turning into repeat calls.
What patient billing questions does a practice get?
| The question | Can the desk answer it? | Who finishes it | Capture before the call ends |
|---|---|---|---|
| What do I owe? | Yes, from the account | Front desk | Identity, the statement or date of service |
| Why do I owe this? | Sometimes: what insurance paid and what was applied to the deductible | Billing, for anything about coding | The exact charge and what the patient expected instead |
| Did my insurance pay? | Usually, from the remittance on the account | Billing, if the claim was denied | Claim date, payer, any letter the patient received |
| Can I pay over time? | Only if the practice has a written payment plan policy | Billing or the practice manager | Balance, what the patient can pay, best contact |
| What will this visit cost? | Not the number; the desk routes it | Whoever prepares estimates | The planned service and date, insurance status |
| I think this bill is wrong | No | Billing | Line item, date of service, why the patient thinks it is wrong |
The last row deserves more respect than it usually gets. In KFF's Health Care Debt Survey, fielded in 2022, 43 percent of all adults said they had received a medical or dental bill they thought contained an error, and 53 percent of adults with health care debt said the same. Among adults with debt who had a billing error, half resolved the dispute and three in ten could not. Patients who call to say a bill is wrong are often right, and a practice that treats the call as a real question finds its own billing problems early.
Scripts for patient billing questions
What do I owe?
Let me pull up your account. Can you confirm your full name and date of birth? ... Your current balance is [amount], from your visit on [date]. Your insurance paid [amount], and [amount] was applied to your deductible. Would you like to pay that today, or would it help to talk about a payment plan?
Why do I owe this?
I can see that [insurance] processed the claim on [date] and applied [amount] to your deductible. If the question is about why the visit was billed the way it was, our billing team will need to look at it. I have written down your question exactly as you asked it, and they will call you by [day and time].
My insurance denied it
I can see the claim was denied on [date]. Sometimes that is a simple fix on our side, and sometimes it needs your insurance company. Our billing team will review it and call you by [day]. Until they do, you do not need to pay that part of the balance.
Only say the last sentence if your practice's policy actually holds collection while a denial is reviewed. If it does not, leave it out. A desk that promises what billing will not honor creates the angriest call of the month.
I cannot afford this
Thank you for telling me. We have [a payment plan, a financial assistance policy, a prompt pay discount], and I would like to get you to the person who can set that up. What is the best number and time to reach you?
What will this cost? (uninsured or self pay)
Because you are paying for this yourself, you are entitled to a good faith estimate of the expected charges. I will make sure that is prepared and sent to you within three business days. What is the best email or address for it?
What will this cost? (insured)
The amount you pay depends on your plan, your deductible and what your insurance allows for the service. Your insurance company can tell you your share. I can give you the service code and our charge for it so you can ask them, and I will pass your question to our billing team as well.
What are the rules on cost questions from uninsured patients?
The good faith estimate rules under the No Surprises Act, at 45 CFR 149.610, are the one part of billing calls with federal deadlines attached. They apply to patients who are uninsured or who are not using insurance for the service, and three parts of them land on the phone.
- The provider must tell these patients, orally, that a good faith estimate is available, both when scheduling and when questions about cost come up
- Any discussion or inquiry about the potential costs of a service under consideration must be treated as a request for an estimate, even if the patient never uses the word
- The estimate is due within three business days of a request; for a scheduled service, within one business day if it is booked three to nine business days out, and within three business days if it is booked ten or more business days out
There is a dispute process behind the estimate. According to CMS, a self pay patient can dispute a bill through the patient provider dispute resolution process when a provider charged $400 or more above its good faith estimate, the care was on or after January 1, 2022, and the initial bill is dated within the last 120 calendar days. Filing costs the patient a $25 administrative fee. The desk does not need to explain all of that on the call. It does need to make sure every self pay cost question becomes an estimate, because a missing estimate is the problem that is hardest to fix later.
How do you stop billing questions turning into repeat calls?
- Give billing one owner, and a callback standard the desk can quote, such as the next business day
- Write the patient's question out in full in the account note, not "pt has billing question"
- Tell the patient the day and time of the callback, then keep it
- Put the billing phone number, billing hours and an online payment option on every statement
- Give billing its own option in the phone tree, so billing callers do not queue behind people booking visits
- Hold collection activity while a dispute is open, if your policy allows it, and say so in writing
- Review a week of billing call notes each quarter; repeated questions about the same charge point to a statement or coding problem, not a phone problem
Can an AI phone agent answer patient billing questions?
Not MedPhone. It does not answer billing questions, read out account balances, verify eligibility or collect payments. When a caller asks about a bill, the call transfers to staff under the transfer rules the practice sets, separately for business hours and after hours. For new patients it does capture insurance details at intake, which helps billing later.
What it does is take the scheduling load off the same phone line. MedPhone answers every caller at once, at any hour, and books, reschedules and cancels appointments in the EHR, so the person who answers billing questions is not also the person booking every visit. It is live in production on athenahealth and speaks English only.
If billing questions are most of your inbound calls, an AI receptionist is the wrong first fix. Look at the statement, the denial rate and the billing callback process first; those are what generate the calls.
See which calls an AI front desk finishes, and which it hands to staff
Sources
Questions people ask
Can the front desk answer patient billing questions?
Some of them. The desk can usually tell a patient their balance and whether insurance has paid, from the account. Questions about coding, denials, disputes and payment plans should go to billing, with the question written out in full and a callback time given.
What should a receptionist say when a patient disputes a bill?
Capture the date of service, the charge and why the patient thinks it is wrong, then say who will review it and when they will call. Do not argue the charge or promise a change the billing team has not agreed to.
Do practices have to give cost estimates over the phone?
For uninsured and self pay patients, the practice must tell them a good faith estimate is available when scheduling and when they ask about costs, and any cost inquiry counts as a request. The written estimate is due within three business days of the request.
Can a patient dispute a bill that is higher than the estimate?
A self pay patient can use the federal patient provider dispute resolution process if the bill is $400 or more above the good faith estimate, the care was on or after January 1, 2022, and the initial bill is dated within the last 120 calendar days. There is a $25 fee to file.
How common are medical billing errors?
In KFF's 2022 Health Care Debt Survey, 43 percent of all adults said they had received a medical or dental bill they thought contained an error. Among adults with health care debt who had a billing error, half resolved the dispute.
Can an AI receptionist take payments or answer billing questions?
MedPhone does neither. Billing calls transfer to staff under rules the practice sets. It handles the scheduling calls on the same line, which frees staff time for billing questions.
Written by
Agni Patel is the founder and CEO of MedPhone, an AI phone agent for medical practices. MedPhone does not collect payments or answer billing questions, so this post is about the calls your staff own.