Smith.ai alternative: how MedPhone compares.

Looking for a Smith.ai alternative for a medical practice? This is an honest side by side, written by MedPhone. Smith.ai is a strong receptionist service for law firms and small businesses, but by its own statement it cannot take calls that involve patient health information.

Last updated:

Smith.ai details checked November 2026 on Smith.ai's own public pages, listed at the bottom. Vendors change pricing and features, so confirm current details with each vendor.

Smith.ai and MedPhone AI both answer calls with AI. Smith.ai sells AI, hybrid AI and human, and human receptionists, with a focus on law firms, billed per call, and says it is not HIPAA compliant. MedPhone is an AI phone agent built only for medical practices, HIPAA Compliant and live on athenahealth, billed on call minutes.

Why practices look for a Smith.ai alternative.

Smith.ai is a well established receptionist service with AI, hybrid and fully human options, a free AI tier, and 500+ North American live agents behind the AI. Its site is built mainly around law firms.

For a medical practice, the deciding fact is on Smith.ai's own site: it is not HIPAA compliant and cannot handle calls that involve protected health information. A patient calling to book, reschedule or ask about a refill gives you exactly that information on most calls.

MedPhone is built for those calls. It is HIPAA Compliant, books and files refill requests in athenahealth, and hands clinical questions to your staff. If your calls carry no patient health information, Smith.ai's live agent backup and Spanish are real advantages.

MedPhone and Smith.ai, side by side.

MedPhone AI compared with Smith.ai
ComparedMedPhone AISmith.ai
Published pricingYes. From $150 a month for 500 minutes, at $0.30 a minute down to $0.145 on bigger plans, and from $0.14 past 50,000 minutes. Minutes past your plan cost your plan's rate. No setup fee, no contract, no per provider or multi location fee.Published, per call. AI Receptionist: Free with 25 calls a month; Pro from $150 a month for 75 calls, $2.50 a call past that; Enterprise from $500 a month for 300 calls. Hybrid and human receptionist plans are also billed per call.
Who it is built forMedical practices only.Mainly law firms ("5,000+ law firms trust Smith.ai"), plus home services, IT, software, finance and other small businesses.
Pricing modelPer practice, on call minutes. Every plan includes every feature; only the minutes and the rate change.Per call. Calls from known spammers are filtered out and not counted.
Patient health informationBuilt for it. HIPAA Compliant. PHI encrypted with AES 256 at rest and TLS 1.3 in transit, and never used to train models. SOC 2 covers the infrastructure MedPhone runs on, not a MedPhone report of its own.Smith.ai says it is not HIPAA compliant and cannot handle calls that involve protected health information. It takes non PHI calls for medical, dental and wellness practices.
Booking into your systemLive in production on athenahealth as a verified Marketplace Partner, writing bookings and refill requests back to the chart.No EHR named. Scheduling with Calendly and other tools; native integrations with Clio, Salesforce and HubSpot, and 5,000+ apps through Zapier or Make.
What it handlesScheduling, rescheduling and cancellations, new patient intake, refill requests, insurance intake, text confirmations, transfers to staff and emergency routing.Answering, intake and lead qualification, FAQs, scheduling, transfers and hand off to a live agent with the AI's notes.
Human backupTransfers to your own staff, by rules you set separately for business hours and after hours.500+ North American live agents take a hand off in real time. Live agents are a per call add on; there is no fee when the AI starts the escalation.
LanguagesEnglish.English and Spanish.
TermsMonth to month. No setup fee, no contract, no per provider fee.Month to month, with 30 days notice to cancel; no setup fees. A 6 month Enterprise plan at a lower rate.
Published proofSynergy Medical, a Michigan family medicine practice on athenahealth: 2,848 calls handled from June to mid August 2026, 65-75% without reaching staff."5,000+ law firms trust Smith.ai" and "25M+ calls handled over 11+ years".

Swipe the table sideways to see both columns.

When Smith.ai is the better pick.

  • Your calls never involve patient health information, for example a wellness business taking general inquiries.
  • You want a live person behind the AI. Smith.ai's AI hands off to 500+ North American live agents; MedPhone transfers to your own staff.
  • You need Spanish, or you get few calls and want to start free. Smith.ai's free AI plan covers 25 calls a month.

When MedPhone is the better pick.

  • Your calls involve patient health information. Smith.ai says it cannot handle those calls; MedPhone is HIPAA Compliant and built for them.
  • You want bookings, reschedules and refill requests written into athenahealth.
  • You want minutes rather than calls. MedPhone's $150 plan is 500 minutes, about 250 calls at about 2 minutes a call; Smith.ai Pro at $150 is 75 calls.

How does Smith.ai pricing compare with MedPhone?

Smith.ai bills per call and MedPhone per minute, so the comparison depends on how long your calls run. At $150 a month, Smith.ai Pro includes 75 calls and MedPhone includes 500 minutes, which is about 250 calls at about 2 minutes each. For a medical practice, though, price comes second: Smith.ai says it cannot take calls that involve patient health information, so ask how it would handle yours before comparing cost.

More on how MedPhone works: full pricing, the athenahealth integration, HIPAA compliance, the Synergy Medical case study, and every comparison we publish.

Where these facts come from.

Everything said about Smith.ai on this page is from these public pages, checked November 2026. If something here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.

MedPhone versus Smith.ai FAQ

The questions practices ask when comparing MedPhone with Smith.ai.

Still have questions?

Can't find the answer you're looking for? Book a 15 minute call and ask us directly.

Book a 15 minute call

No, by its own statement. Smith.ai says it is not HIPAA compliant and cannot handle calls that involve protected health information, though it takes non PHI calls for medical, dental and wellness practices. MedPhone is HIPAA Compliant: PHI is encrypted with AES 256 at rest and TLS 1.3 in transit, and never used to train models.

Smith.ai bills per call. Its AI Receptionist is free for 25 calls a month, then Pro starts at $150 a month for 75 calls, with $2.50 a call past that. MedPhone bills per minute: $150 a month for 500 minutes, then $0.30 a minute on that plan, with no setup fee or contract.

Smith.ai names no EHR. It schedules through Calendly and other tools, and connects to Clio, Salesforce, HubSpot and apps through Zapier or Make. MedPhone books, reschedules and cancels directly in athenahealth, where it is a verified Marketplace Partner.

Not its own. MedPhone transfers calls to your staff, by rules you set separately for business hours and after hours. Smith.ai can hand a call to one of its own live agents, which is a real advantage if you have no one to take transfers.

No. MedPhone works in English. Smith.ai's AI Receptionist offers English and Spanish.

If your calls involve patient health information, as most scheduling, refill and intake calls do, MedPhone, because Smith.ai says it cannot handle those calls. If your calls carry none and you want a live agent behind the AI, Smith.ai is worth a look.

Compare them on your own calls.

Fifteen minutes. Bring your call volume and your EHR, and get a quote for your practice.

Book a demo