# How to offer same day appointments at a medical practice

> Carve out or open access, how many slots to hold and when to release them, who decides which caller gets one, and why the phone at 8am decides whether any of it works.

Source: https://medphone.ai/blog/how-to-offer-same-day-appointments

Author: Agni Patel, MedPhone AI. Published 2026-11-20.

**To offer same day appointments, a practice has to decide two things before it touches the phones: how much of each day stays unbooked until that morning, and who is allowed to book into it. Get those right and same day access mostly runs itself. Get them wrong and you either waste held slots or send patients to urgent care while your own schedule has gaps.**

**Same day appointments** are visits booked and seen on the day the patient asks. A practice can offer them in two ways: by holding back a set number of slots each day for same day requests, known as a carve out, or by leaving most of the schedule open until the day itself and doing today's work today, known as open or advanced access.

## Why offer same day appointments at all?

Because lead time is one of the most reliable predictors of a missed visit. A 2018 systematic review of no show research in Health Policy, covering 105 studies, found that long lead time and a history of previous no shows were the most commonly reported significant predictors. A visit booked this morning for this afternoon rarely gets forgotten.

The best known evidence for going further comes from Mark Murray and Catherine Tantau, writing in Family Practice Management in 2000 about their Kaiser Permanente clinic in Roseville, California. After moving to advanced access, the wait for a routine appointment fell from 55 days to one day in under a year. The share of patients who saw their own physician rose from 47 percent to 80 percent, and visits per patient per year fell to 10 percent below the previous baseline.

That was one well run clinic, and not every practice that has tried open access has kept it. But the direction is consistent: shorter waits, better continuity, fewer wasted slots.

## Carve out or open access: which model fits your practice?

| Model | How it works | Where it works | Where it breaks |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Carve out | A fixed number of slots per provider per day stay empty for same day requests | Practices with long booked out schedules that want a start | Held slots fill by 9am, or sit empty if the rules are too strict |
| Open access | Most slots stay open until the day; only clinically necessary follow ups are booked ahead | Practices whose supply roughly matches demand | Needs a backlog worked down first, and discipline to keep it down |
| Hybrid with release time | Slots are held for same day, then released to anyone at a set time | Most independent practices starting out | Release time set by habit instead of by your demand data |

Murray and Tantau were blunt about carve outs. Slots are either booked ahead or held for urgent needs, so a nonurgent request today gets pushed into the future anyway, and staff end up telling patients to call back on the day they want care. Their alternative needs real preparation: they expected six to eight weeks of seeing extra patients to work down the existing backlog, and they cut appointment types down to a handful with one standard length.

For most independent practices I talk to, the hybrid is the realistic starting point. It is cheap to try, it is reversible, and it generates the demand data you need to decide whether to go further.

## How many same day slots should you hold?

Hold what your demand data says, by day of the week. Murray and Tantau observed that same day demand is more predictable than it feels, and that it peaks in the morning, drops over lunch and falls sharply after about 2pm. Here is how to size it.

1. For four to six weeks, count every same day request by weekday, including the ones you turned away or sent to urgent care. The turned away ones are the number most practices do not have
2. Average the requests per weekday. Monday is usually the highest. Hold that many slots per day across your providers, plus a small buffer
3. Spread the held slots through the day, weighted toward the morning when requests arrive, but keep some in the afternoon for patients who call at lunch
4. Set a release time, such as 11am for afternoon slots, after which unfilled held slots open to anyone. Adjust it once you see how often slots go unused
5. Review weekly for the first two months: held slots that went unused, requests turned away, and how often patients saw their own provider

> If you held ten slots and turned away four patients by 9:30, the answer is not a stricter rule about who gets a slot. It is more slots, or fewer visits booked weeks ahead that could have been booked this week.

## Who decides which caller gets a same day appointment?

Write it down, because otherwise it is decided by whoever answers the phone. Most practices end up with three groups.

- Routine same day requests that need no clinical judgment, such as a form, a blood pressure check or a medication follow up the provider has marked as fine to book. Front desk books them
- Callers describing symptoms. Somebody clinical decides how soon they need to be seen, whether that is today, tomorrow, urgent care or the emergency department. Front desk should not make that call
- Callers with emergency symptoms, who are told to hang up and call 911 before anything else happens

A short script keeps the routine group fast. Offering two specific times works better than asking when the patient is free.

> We have an opening today with Dr. [Name] at 10:40 or at 2:15. Would either of those work for you?

> I want to make sure you are seen at the right time, so I am going to connect you with our nurse, who can help decide that. Please stay on the line.

Related: [What a nurse triage line does with symptom calls](https://medphone.ai/blog/what-is-a-nurse-triage-line)

## Why same day appointments depend on the phone

Same day demand arrives at exactly the moment your phone line is least able to take it. The patient who woke up needing to be seen calls at 8am, along with everyone else. If they hit a busy signal or a ten minute hold, some of them give up and go to urgent care, and your held slot sits empty until the release time. Same day capacity that cannot be booked is not capacity.

This is the part of same day access where MedPhone helps. It answers every caller at once, reads live availability in the EHR, and books same day requests within the rules you set for which slots are held and who can have them. When a patient cancels, the change is written to the schedule during the call, so that slot becomes same day capacity for the next caller.

The honest limit matters more here than in most of our use cases. MedPhone does not triage and does not give clinical advice. A caller who describes symptoms is transferred to your staff under the rules you set, and callers with emergency symptoms are told to call 911. If most of your same day demand is sick visits that need a clinical decision, MedPhone will transfer much of it, and the gain is in answering the call at once and taking the routine calls out of the way, not in booking the sick visits itself.

Related: [What AI appointment scheduling books and what it transfers](https://medphone.ai/blog/ai-appointment-scheduling-for-medical-practices) · [Five fixes for missed calls at the 8am rush](https://medphone.ai/blog/how-to-reduce-missed-calls-at-a-medical-practice) · [Voice AI in family medicine, where MedPhone is live](https://medphone.ai/voice-ai-family-medicine)

## How do you know same day access is working?

Track five numbers monthly. None of them needs new software.

| Measure | How to get it | What good looks like |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Third next available appointment | Count forward to the third open routine slot for each provider, at the same time each week | Falling, toward a few days |
| Same day requests turned away | A tally at the front desk, or a note code in the EHR | Close to zero for routine requests |
| Held slots unused at day end | Schedule report at close | Low, but not always zero |
| Continuity | Share of visits with the patient's own provider | Steady or rising |
| No show rate by lead time | Schedule report split by days between booking and visit | Same day visits well below long lead visits |

Third next available is used instead of the next available slot because one cancellation can make the first open slot look misleadingly close. If it is falling and turned away requests are near zero, the model is working.

[See what unanswered morning calls cost you](https://medphone.ai/tools/missed-call-calculator)

Sources:
- [Murray and Tantau, Same day appointments: exploding the access paradigm, Family Practice Management, 2000](https://www.aafp.org/pubs/fpm/issues/2000/0900/p45.html)
- [Dantas et al, No shows in appointment scheduling: a systematic literature review, Health Policy, 2018](https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:eee:hepoli:v:122:y:2018:i:4:p:412-421)

## Questions people ask

### How many same day appointments should a practice hold?

Hold as many as your own demand data says, by weekday. Count every same day request for four to six weeks, including the ones you turned away, average them per weekday, and hold that many slots plus a small buffer, with a release time for any that go unused.

### What is the difference between open access and a carve out?

A carve out holds a fixed number of slots each day for same day requests and books the rest ahead. Open access, also called advanced access, leaves most of the schedule open until the day itself and books ahead only clinically necessary follow ups and patients who prefer a later date.

### Do same day appointments reduce no shows?

They tend to, because long lead time is one of the most commonly reported predictors of a no show in the research. A visit booked the same morning gives the patient little time to forget or for plans to change.

### Who should decide if a patient needs a same day appointment?

For routine requests, front desk staff following written rules. For callers describing symptoms, a clinician or nurse should decide how soon they need to be seen. Callers with emergency symptoms should be told to hang up and call 911.

### How long does it take to switch to open access scheduling?

Murray and Tantau expected about six to eight weeks of seeing extra patients to work down the existing backlog before open access could run normally. Plan for that period, and set a date after which routine visits are no longer booked far ahead.

### Can an AI receptionist book same day appointments?

It can book routine same day requests into the slots your rules allow, reading live availability in the EHR. It should not decide how urgently a patient with symptoms needs to be seen. MedPhone transfers those callers to staff, and tells callers with emergency symptoms to call 911.
