# How to get more new patients at a medical practice, starting with the leak most practices ignore

> Most practices spend money getting prospective patients to call, then lose a share of them on the call itself. Find that leak first, then spend on the rest.

Source: https://medphone.ai/blog/how-to-get-more-new-patients

Author: Agni Patel, MedPhone AI. Published 2026-11-20.

**If you want to get more new patients, the cheapest place to start is usually not marketing. It is your own phone line. Most practices spend real money and effort getting a prospective patient to call, then lose a share of those callers on the call itself: on hold, in a phone tree, in a voicemail box at 5:30pm, or with a front desk that is checking someone in and cannot pick up.**

That is not an argument against marketing, referrals or reviews. It is an argument about order. Pouring more callers into a line that drops some of them raises your cost per new patient. Fix the leak and every other effort is worth more.

## What actually brings new patients to a practice?

**New patient acquisition** for a medical practice is the chain of steps between someone deciding they need a doctor and that person attending a first visit: being found, being chosen, getting through, getting booked and showing up. A practice gets more new patients by widening the weakest link in that chain, which is rarely the first one.

People arrive by recommendation first and convenience second. Accenture surveyed 8,000 US adults who had sought or received care in the previous year. About one in five had switched providers in that year, and nearly 90 percent of those who switched said they did so because the organization was hard to do business with. Some 70 percent of switchers cited access as a deciding factor, and 53 percent chose their new provider based on a recommendation or referral.

Read those numbers from the other side. A large share of the patients looking for a new practice are leaving an old one because it was hard to reach. They are exactly the people who will hang up on your hold music.

## Where do new patients leak out before they book?

At every step, but the steps are not equally expensive to fix.

| Step | Where it leaks | How to check |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Found | Wrong hours or phone number on your listings, no mention that you accept new patients | Search for your practice the way a stranger would |
| Chosen | Unclear which insurance you take, no way to tell who the providers are | Read your own website as if you were new to town |
| Got through | Busy signals, long holds, a menu with the new patient option buried, voicemail after hours | Call your own line at 8:05am, 12:15pm and 5:45pm |
| Booked | No new patient slots for weeks, or a message taken instead of a booking | Ask how far out the next new patient visit is |
| Showed up | No confirmation, no reminder, a long wait that lets them book elsewhere | Compare new patient no shows with established patients |

The third and fourth rows are where most practices are weakest and least aware of it, because nobody inside the practice ever experiences them. In a 2017 MGMA Stat poll of 1,334 practice leaders, 42 percent said incoming calls are answered by an automated phone tree, and 19 percent overall said callers are sent to a wait queue. The phone is still the main door, too: in a July 2025 MGMA Stat poll, 71 percent of medical groups said fewer than a quarter of their patients schedule through digital tools.

The fourth row has a ceiling you cannot ignore. In AMN Healthcare's 2022 survey of 1,034 physician offices in 15 large metro areas, the average wait for a new patient appointment was 26 days. Family medicine was shorter, at 20.6 days. A caller offered a slot a month out is easy to lose to the practice down the road with one next week.

## How do you find out if your phone is losing new patients?

You can answer this in a week without buying anything.

1. Export your phone system's call log and count abandoned calls by hour of day. Most practices find them stacked in the first hour after opening and over lunch
2. Call your own main line as a new patient at three different times. Count the rings, the seconds of recorded message, the menu options before "new patients", and the minutes to a person
3. Call after hours and listen to what a prospective patient hears. Does it offer anything except a voicemail box?
4. Count voicemails from unknown numbers last month, and how many were returned the same day
5. Ask every new patient at their first visit how they found you, and whether they had to call more than once

Then put a number on it. Our missed call calculator walks through the arithmetic from your call volume and abandonment rate to new patients and revenue, without the inflated assumptions most vendor calculators use.

Related: [Missed call revenue calculator](https://medphone.ai/tools/missed-call-calculator) · [How many calls does a medical practice actually miss?](https://medphone.ai/blog/how-many-calls-does-a-practice-miss)

## How to get more new patients from the calls you already get

These are in order of cost, cheapest first.

- Say "new patients" in the first sentence of your greeting, not as option seven. Someone deciding whether to join your practice should not have to sit through instructions written for existing patients
- Shorten the recorded message. Every second before a person or a useful menu is a second for the caller to give up
- Take the phone away from whoever is checking patients in during the first hour. One person on phones only, at the peak, does more than two people splitting attention
- Book on the first call. A new patient who gets "someone will call you back" is a new patient who keeps calling other practices
- Protect new patient slots in provider templates, so the answer to "when can I be seen?" is not a month away by default
- Return new patient voicemails within the hour during business hours, and first thing the next morning for overnight calls
- Send a text confirmation with the address and what to bring, so the booking turns into a visit
- Answer after hours. Plenty of working adults only get a moment to call in the evening. An answering service that takes a message helps a little; something that can book the visit helps more

The last item is where an AI phone agent fits. MedPhone answers every call at any hour, every caller at once, takes new patient intake and insurance details, books the visit in the EHR and sends a text confirmation. At Synergy Medical, a family medicine practice in Michigan on athenahealth, it handled 2,848 inbound calls between June and mid August 2026, starting at around 53 percent finished without staff on day one and improving as call flows were tuned.

Related: [Doctors office voicemail greeting scripts](https://medphone.ai/blog/doctors-office-voicemail-greeting-scripts) · [After hours answering for medical practices](https://medphone.ai/blog/after-hours-answering-for-medical-practices) · [Fixes for missed calls that cost nothing](https://medphone.ai/blog/how-to-reduce-missed-calls-at-a-medical-practice)

## What else moves new patient numbers?

Once the phone is not leaking, the usual levers work better.

- Referral relationships. More than half of switchers in the Accenture survey chose their new provider on a recommendation or referral. Visit the specialists and urgent care centers that send you patients, and make it easy for their staff to book with you
- Listings. Keep hours, phone number, insurance and "accepting new patients" accurate everywhere a stranger might look
- Your website. Insurance accepted, providers with photos, and the phone number in the top corner of every page
- Online scheduling for the patients who prefer it. It will not replace the phone for most practices, but it should be there
- Your existing patients. Ask satisfied patients to leave a review, and make sure the patients you already have can reach you. Retention is new patient acquisition you do not have to pay for

## When will none of this help?

Three situations, and it is better to know them now.

When your schedule is full. If new patient visits are already booked weeks out, more callers mean longer waits, not more patients. That is a capacity problem: provider hours, templates, perhaps another clinician. No phone fix touches it.

When you are not in the patient's network. If the plans that dominate your area are ones you do not take, answering faster just tells people no more quickly.

When call volume is low. A quiet practice with a responsive front desk may not have a phone leak at all. Check the call log before assuming you do. And note what an AI phone agent will not do for you: MedPhone does not run outbound calling or marketing campaigns, does not manage reviews or listings, and works in English only. It fixes getting through and getting booked. The rest of the chain is still yours.

[Estimate what your missed calls cost](https://medphone.ai/tools/missed-call-calculator)

Related: [How to reduce patient no shows](https://medphone.ai/blog/how-to-reduce-patient-no-shows) · [How to measure and improve the patient phone experience](https://medphone.ai/blog/patient-phone-experience)

Sources:
- [American Hospital Association Market Scan, summarizing Accenture's survey of 8,000 US adults, May 2024](https://www.aha.org/aha-center-health-innovation-market-scan/2024-05-28-survey-without-top-notch-consumer-experience-expect-patient-flight)
- [AMN Healthcare, physician appointment wait times survey, September 2022](https://www.amnhealthcare.com/blog/physician/perm/physician-appointment-wait-times-getting-longer/)
- [MGMA Stat, how practices answer incoming calls, March 2017](https://www.mgma.com/mgma-stats/practice-leaders-most-phone-calls-are-personally-answered)
- [MGMA Stat, patient digital self scheduling, July 2025](https://www.mgma.com/mgma-stat/meeting-pressure-on-patient-digital-self-scheduling)

## Questions people ask

### How can a medical practice get more new patients?

Start by making sure the patients already trying to reach you can get through and get booked on the first call. Then invest in referral relationships, accurate listings and a clear website. Marketing spend works best once the phone is not losing callers.

### How do doctors attract new patients without advertising?

Through referrals and recommendations, which drove more than half of provider switches in one large Accenture survey, and through being easy to reach. Answering calls promptly, booking on the first call and offering after hours coverage keep the patients that word of mouth sends you.

### How long do new patients wait for a doctor's appointment?

In AMN Healthcare's 2022 survey of 15 large metro areas, the average wait for a new patient physician appointment was 26 days, and 20.6 days for family medicine. Waits vary widely by specialty and city.

### How do I know if my practice is losing new patients on the phone?

Check abandoned calls by hour in your phone system, call your own line at busy times and after hours, and count unreturned voicemails from unknown numbers. If callers are abandoning at the morning peak or reaching voicemail in the evening, you are almost certainly losing some new patients.

### Does online scheduling bring in more new patients?

It helps the patients who prefer it, and it is worth offering. But in a 2025 MGMA Stat poll, 71 percent of medical groups said fewer than a quarter of patients self schedule digitally, so for most practices the phone remains the main way new patients book.

### Should a medical practice answer the phone after hours?

If new patients call you in the evening, yes, ideally with something that can book the visit rather than take a message. Emergencies still need a 911 instruction and clinical calls need your on call path.
