# athenahealth patient portal vs phone: which patient requests belong where

> The athenahealth patient portal can take refills, bookings, forms, payments and messages off the phone. Federal survey data says most patients still prefer to talk to someone for some things. How to split the work between the two.

Source: https://medphone.ai/blog/athenahealth-patient-portal-vs-phone

Author: Agni Patel, MedPhone AI. Published 2026-11-20.

**The athenahealth patient portal, and the athenaPatient app that sits on top of it, can take a large share of routine requests off your phones: prescription renewal requests, self scheduling, self check in, secure messages, lab result notifications and bill payment. It cannot take all of them, and it should not try. In federal survey data, the most common reason patients give for not using a portal is that they would rather speak to someone directly. The practical question for an athenahealth practice is not portal or phone. It is which request goes where, and how to make each route work.**

## What can patients do in the athenahealth patient portal?

athenahealth's athenaOne Base service description, Fall 2026 Release Edition, lists these patient facing features across the Patient Portal and athenaPatient. Which ones your patients see depends on what your practice turns on.

- Book appointments from the visit reasons you permit, and reschedule or cancel within a window you set
- Request prescription renewals from the Medications section or with a Prescriptions and Refills message; the request lands as a patient case in your Clinical Inbox
- Send secure messages with PDF, JPG or PNG attachments, kept in the patient record
- Complete self check in before the visit: confirm details, upload an insurance card, pay a copay, fill in screening questionnaires, sign consent forms and update medications and pharmacy
- View lab results, often after a ResultsCall notification by phone, email or text; athenahealth can flag results a patient has not viewed within a time you set
- Pay outstanding balances, or set up a payment plan as part of self check in
- Choose how they are notified, by email, phone or text, and grant family members access to their account
- Use the portal in English or Spanish; athenahealth translates portal functions but not messages between patient and practice

The Fall 2026 edition also describes an AI Patient Assistant in athenaPatient and the Patient Portal that helps patients with administrative tasks such as managing pharmacies and requesting refills. athenahealth says it is not intended to give medical advice, escalates patient reported emergencies, and sends anything needing clinical judgment back to the practice.

## Why do patients still call when they have an athenahealth patient portal?

Because most of them are not using it for the thing they are calling about. ONC's 2024 data brief found 77 percent of individuals were offered online access to their records or a patient portal, and 65 percent were offered access and used it at least once in the past year. Once a year is not the same as every time.

When ONC asked people who had been offered a portal but did not use it why, the answers in its 2020 data were blunt. 69 percent preferred to speak with their health care provider directly. 63 percent said they did not need it. 24 percent were concerned about privacy or security, 24 percent had trouble logging in, and 20 percent were uncomfortable with computers.

There is a lever in the same data. In 2024, 87 percent of people whose provider encouraged them to use the portal went on to access it, against 57 percent of those who were not encouraged. What the front desk says at check in matters more than any setting.

## Which patient requests belong in the portal, and which on the phone?

My rule of thumb: the portal is best for requests that are complete in one message and not urgent. The phone is best for anything that needs a back and forth, anything time sensitive, and anyone who prefers it.

| Request | Best route | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Routine refill for a current medication | Portal, or phone if the patient calls | Complete in one request, and either way it should reach the Clinical Inbox for a clinician to approve |
| Book a routine follow up or physical | Portal self scheduling, if the visit type is open online | The patient can see real times and pick one |
| Reschedule to a specific day or provider | Portal within your window; otherwise phone | Often needs a back and forth about options |
| Forms, insurance card, copay | Portal self check in | Saves time at the window and is easier to do at home |
| Question about a bill | Portal message or phone | Simple ones suit a message; disputes need a person |
| New symptoms or feeling worse | Phone, to clinical staff | Needs clinical judgment and should not wait in an inbox |
| Emergency symptoms | 911 | Neither the portal nor the front desk is the right place |
| Anything from a patient who will not use the portal | Phone | Forcing them online just delays the request |

## How do you move more requests to the athenahealth patient portal?

Gently, and at the moments when patients are already paying attention.

1. Invite every patient to Portal Registration from athenaOne, then complete it at check in. athenahealth says patients can finish registration in office, by email, by text, at a kiosk or in the athenaPatient app
2. Have the front desk say one sentence at check out about what the portal is for. The ONC encouragement gap suggests this is the single cheapest thing you can do
3. Use the GroupCall portal adoption campaign, which athenahealth lists among its prebuilt standard campaigns
4. Turn on self check in, so the reminder a patient already gets leads into the portal for a reason they care about
5. Mention the portal for refills in your phone greeting, briefly, without making callers sit through it
6. Track progress on athenahealth's Patient Digital Engagement Index dashboard, which shows digital activity by provider and department and benchmarks against similar practices

What not to do: make the portal the only route. A patient who is pushed online for a refill they wanted to request by phone tends to call again later, and some will not use the portal at all.

## What does the phone still need to cover?

Everything the portal is the wrong tool for, which is still a lot. Clinical calls and anything urgent. Patients who are not registered or will not log in. Reschedules outside your portal window. New patients who want to ask a question before booking. And evenings and weekends, when people remember they need to call.

That leftover phone work is the part most athenahealth practices struggle to staff, because it arrives at the busiest times of day and keeps coming after hours.

## Where does MedPhone fit, and where does it not?

MedPhone covers the phone side of this split. It is an AI phone agent that answers every caller at once, 24/7, and finishes the routine requests on the call: booking, rescheduling and cancelling in athenahealth, taking new patient intake, taking insurance details, and capturing refill requests as tasks in the provider's clinical inbox, where approval stays with the clinician. Clinical questions and symptoms transfer to your staff by rules you set, and callers describing emergency symptoms are told to call 911.

It is a verified athenahealth Marketplace Partner, in production since June 2026 at Synergy Medical, a family medicine practice in Michigan, where it handled 2,848 inbound calls between June and mid August 2026.

Where it does not fit: MedPhone does not manage the patient portal, answer portal messages or handle portal registration. It works in English only, while athenahealth's portal offers Spanish for its functions, so a practice with many Spanish speaking callers should weigh that. And if your patients have largely moved online and your phones are already answered promptly, the portal may be all you need. MedPhone is for the calls that remain.

Related: [MedPhone for athenahealth practices](https://medphone.ai/athenahealth) · [How to handle prescription refill requests by phone](https://medphone.ai/blog/prescription-refill-requests-by-phone) · [What patients experience when they call your practice](https://medphone.ai/blog/patient-phone-experience) · [How MedPhone handles patient data](https://medphone.ai/hipaa-compliance)

[Hear how MedPhone handles a refill call](https://medphone.ai/contact)

Sources:
- [athenahealth, athenaOne Base Service Description, Fall 2026 Release Edition, published November 18, 2026](https://www.athenahealth.com/sites/default/files/media_docs/athenaOne-Service-Description.pdf)
- [ASTP/ONC Data Brief 77, Individuals' access and use of patient portals and smartphone health apps, 2024](https://healthit.gov/data/data-briefs/individuals-access-and-use-patient-portals-and-smartphone-health-apps-2024/)
- [Johnson, Richwine and Patel, ONC Data Brief 57, Individuals' access and use of patient portals and smartphone health apps, 2020, September 2021](https://healthit.gov/data/data-briefs/individuals-access-and-use-patient-portals-and-smartphone-health-apps-2020/)

## Questions people ask

### What can patients do in the athenahealth patient portal?

Depending on what the practice enables, patients can book and manage appointments, request prescription renewals, send secure messages, complete self check in, view lab results, pay balances and choose how they are notified. The athenaPatient app offers most of the same on a phone and requires the Patient Portal.

### Where do athenahealth portal refill requests go?

athenahealth's service description says portal prescription renewal requests appear in the Clinical Inbox as a patient case. Staff process the request and can reply to the patient, who sees the response in their portal message inbox.

### Is the athenahealth patient portal available in Spanish?

Yes, for portal functions. athenahealth says patients can choose English or Spanish content, but it does not translate messages between patient and practice, the clinical record, or content unique to the practice.

### Why do patients call instead of using the portal?

In ONC's 2020 survey data, 69 percent of people offered a portal who did not use it said they preferred to speak with their provider directly, and 63 percent said they did not need it. Login trouble, privacy worries and discomfort with computers each came up for about a fifth to a quarter.

### How do we get more patients to use the athenahealth patient portal?

Encourage it in person. ONC found 87 percent of patients encouraged by their provider accessed their portal, against 57 percent who were not. Then make registration easy at check in and give patients a reason to log in, such as self check in.

### Should we stop taking refill requests by phone?

Usually not. Steer patients toward the portal, but keep the phone route for those who will not use it. Either way, the request should end up as a task in the clinical inbox for a clinician to approve, not as a message someone has to retype.
